About Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria & Pasta and reviews

Serving New Bern for over 30 years!

We deliver all of our menu items!
Call 252-633-5444 Now to place an order!
Open Everyday at 11am-11pm Fri and Sat open till Midnight!
Full ABC permits! Our mixologists can concoct anything your taste buds can come up with! Nightly specials and Bud Light, Blue Moon and Yuengling  on tap!

Antipasto Salad
Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, black and green olives, ham salami and cheese. Served with your choice of dressing and garlic bread.
Small                                                                          5.95
Large                                                                          7.95
House Salad
Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cucumbers. Served with your choice of dressing.
Small                                                                                                3.25
Large                                                                                                4.25
Add Cheese                                                                                      1.25

Grilled Pizza
A white pizza (no sauce) topped with sliced tomatoes onions, green peppers and cheddar cheese. Serves two.                                                         8.95
Caitlyn Smith        
For those who like it HOT! A hand thrown crust with very little sauce, covered with sliced jalapeno, peppers and cheddar cheese.                               8.95
Garlic Bread
Made from scratch in our kitchen everyday, this loaf of crusty bread with garlic butter goes great with any dish!                                                           1.65
Peasant Bread
Garlic butter and melted cheese.                                                         4.45
Add any of our pizza topping!                                                               1.00
Homemade using only fresh ingredients, covered with sauce and melted cheese. Served with garlic bread.
2 Meatballs                                                                                        4.25
3 Meatballs                                                                                        4.75
4 Meatballs                                                                                        5.25
Served with your choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch dressing.
1/2 Dozen                                                                                         3.95
Dozen                                                                                               6.95
Bread Sticks     
Served with your choice of meat or tomato sauce.                                 3.25

Ham & Swiss
Fresh lettuce, tomato and onion, mayo or oil and vinegar. Served hot or cold.
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                7.95
Turkey & Provolone
Fresh lettuce, tomato and onion, mayo or oil and vinegar. Served hot or cold.
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                7.95
Roast Beef & Provolone    
Fresh lettuce, tomato and onion, mayo or oil and vinegar. Served hot or cold.
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                7.95
Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo or oil and vinegar. Served hot or cold.
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                7.95
Meatball Sub
Topped with meat sauce and mozzarella cheese.
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                7.95
Tuna Melt                       
Fresh lettuce, tomato and onion with American cheese.
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                7.95
Steak & Cheese
Grilled Steak with onion and green peppers
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                7.95
Breezie's Special        
Grilled steak, ham, onion, and green peppers and melted cheddar cheese
Half                                                                    4.45
Whole                                                                8.95


Regular Thin, Traditional Hand Thrown or Chicago Deep Dish

10"                       12"                   15"                    16"

Cheese                6.55                      9.25                 11.50                          15.50

1 Topping           7.65                     10.50               12.95                          15.95

2 Topping          8.65                     11.50                15.50                         16.50

Each Additional Topping   1.05                      1.25                  1.50                          1.85

Choose your Toppings

Ground Beef           Onion             Green Olives        Sausage           Green Peppers         

 Pepperoni          Ham                 Pineapple        Mushrooms     Black Olives

Cheddar Cheese      Sliced Tomatoes          Jalapenos          Banana Peppers       Italian Sausage     

Specialty Pizza

                           10"       12"         15"         16"                                                                                  

37th Street Special   

Ground beef, Sausage, pepperoni, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, black and green olives,         

                                         10.95                   15.95                          16.95                    18.95

Mamma Capriglione's Style

Pepperoni, onions, green peppers, ground beef, ham, sausage, mushrooms, Italian sausage, black and green olives, and extra cheese!!

                                       11.95                   15.95                         17.95                  19.95

Taco Pizza

Hamburger, and onions topped with lettuce, tomatoes, black olives and jalapenos, cheddar cheese, severed with sour cream and taco sauce. 

                                10.95                   15.95                         16.95                  18.95

Vegetarian Delight

Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, pineapple, black and green olives, banana peppers, sliced tomatoes.

                                        10.95                   15.95                        16.95                  18.95


Mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese and ham; folded over and basted with garlic butter; served with tomato sauce

                                                                         Small                         Medium                    Large                  

                                                                          9.95                             11.95                       15.55


Tomato sauce, cheese, and your favorite toppings; folded over, basted with garlic butter, and baked golden brown

                                                            10"                    12"                   15"              

    Cheese                                            7.95                   9.95                11.95            

1 Topping                                            8.95                  10.95               12.95

2 Toppings                                           9.95                  11.95               15.95 

3 Toppings                                          10.95                 12.95               15.95

New York style served with your choice of Chocolate syrup, Strawberry, or Cherry.
Plain 3.25
With toppings 3.75

with meat or tomato sauce                                               7.95                
with two meatballs                                                           1.50
with Italian link sausage                                                   2.75
with melted mozzarella cheese                                        1.25
Papa Capriglione Spaghetti
An extra large portion of pasta with extra mushrooms, meatballs, meat or tomato sauce and melted cheese. You may need help with this one!            
Truly one of our house specialties. Filled with beef, pork a blend cheeses, covered with meat or tomato sauce and melted cheese.
Pasta stuffed with a blend of cheese and served with meat or tomato sauce
Jumbo Shells
Yummy shells stuffed with a blend of cheese and served with meat or tomato sauce.
Stuffed with pork, beef and cheese with meat or tomato sauce.
Baked Ziti
Ziti noodles mixed with ricotta cheese and baked with sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Side dish of extra sauce
Add mushrooms to any pasta dish




This place has decent food. A good selection of pizzas and other Italian food. The taco pizza is good except that it is difficult to eat. Shredded lettuce would make so much more sense. Atmosphere is very casual. The Italian dressing is really nice too.



I was recommended to come here by a fellow employee who said their food and service was amazing, but reminded me he hadnt been there in a few years. This restaurant did not live up to the expectations.. The food was okay and the service...



We ordered from them for the second time delivery to a local hotel while we were visiting. We appreciate that they deliver to hotels and brought it right to the pool. Very friendly delivery driver. Appreciated that they send plates and napkins. Some order mix...



Our very favorite item on the menu are their calzones! You can pick "three" ingredients to put inside your calzone. Since we already know we will taking home left overs, can I recommend the antipasto salad?!? Perfect combination.



I always love this place. Great people on the staff, lots of big, and quality Italian choices. Always a pleasure to enjoy a nice casual reasonably priced meal there.


Andre Z

I had a tasty calzone sausage, pep and cheese on my first visit and then Manicotti love this place!!



We went here after trying two other places in town and not happy with those. This place is very, very good. We had the meat lovers deep dish pizza, it was the best!! The bread in his recipe is so delicious. The ice tea is...



Atmosphere is nothing to write home about but the food surely makes up for it! Their hand thrown pizza is WONDERFUL with all the toppings and can also say that their meatballs are delicious. Great food!


Frank M

I had dinner at the bar one night it was average at best. First air conditioning was not working, so it was hot in that tiny little room. I ordered Papa's spaghetti and it was good.



The food is great and the price is low. I always get the meatballs and lasigna. Fresh bread that comes with it is yummy. Very good sweet tea. Waitresses are pretty too.